Post Page Advertisement [Top]

Sportsbook lounge with odds screens at Fontainebleau Las Vegas
Photo: Dialh / CC BY 4.0 via Wikimedia Commons.

Sports betting handle in the United States is no longer growing, and prediction markets are the obvious suspect. State-regulated books posted year-over-year handle declines in eight of the last ten months, and the slide began in December 2025, the same month Kalshi's monthly sports trading volume first crossed 5 billion dollars.

The combined picture through the first eight months of 2026 is 101.7 billion dollars in handle across 32 comparable jurisdictions, up only 2.5 percent from a year earlier, and that includes the World Cup summer. Strip out June and July, the months the tournament inflated every betting product, and the underlying handle was down 2.9 percent. This is what a maturing market looks like when a rival format starts eating the margins.

Eight down months and one clean break

The monthly record is stark. Excluding the two World Cup months, handle fell in every month from December 2025 through September 2026 except none: eight straight down months, with September closing at 13.06 billion dollars across 30 jurisdictions, down 0.7 percent from a year earlier.

The timing is the tell. December 2025 is the month Kalshi's sports trading passed 5 billion dollars in monthly volume, and the handle decline starts there. Before that month, state books had grown more than 20 percent year over year in 2024 and kept double-digit momentum into late 2025. The break in the curve is as clean as market data gets.

Promotional calendars complicate the read: books cut sign-up offers in the same window, so part of the slide is operator discipline rather than customer loss, a caveat both sides of the exchange debate cite. The counter-argument is that disciplined books should still grow revenue, and in most months they have, which is why the hold story matters as much as the volume story.

Correlation is not causation, but the numbers line up uncomfortably well. Analysts who tracked Kalshi's monthly sports volume against the year-over-year handle change across the same window found a correlation of minus 0.77, meaning the stronger the exchange month, the weaker the book month.

What moved, and where

The declines are not evenly spread. Mississippi's handle fell 20.7 percent, Kansas dropped 11.2 percent, Pennsylvania 6.3 percent, New Jersey 4.2 percent and Nevada 4.1 percent in the most recent comparisons. New Jersey tells the annual story: 12.8 billion dollars of handle in 2024 fell to 12.2 billion in 2025, the first back-to-back decline for a flagship market.

Growth did not stop everywhere. New York, the biggest market, still added 3.7 percent to reach 19.37 billion dollars, and North Carolina grew fastest at 12.4 percent. The pattern fits a market where mature states have saturated while newer ones climb, overlaid with a national leakage toward exchanges.

How much of the slowdown is really prediction markets? Analysts estimate 4 to 5 percent of sportsbook handle has migrated to exchanges, which would explain about a third of the slowdown. Eilers and Krejcik put prediction-market handle-equivalent volume near 2 billion dollars in March 2026, about 11 percent of the combined market, with most of that trading coming from states that have no legal online sportsbooks at all, led by California and Texas. DraftKings chief executive Jason Robins has pushed back with his own number: only about 1 percent customer overlap between his book and exchange users.

Why books are still making money

The counterintuitive part is that falling handle has not meant falling revenue. Operators have lifted their hold, the share of wagers they keep, and the result is revenue growth in several slipping states. Pennsylvania is the cleanest example: handle down 6.3 percent, revenue up 6.5 percent, with hold expanding from 9.2 percent to 10.5 percent. Massachusetts shows the same shape, with handle up just 1.7 percent while revenue rose 6.0 percent.

The state treasuries are still paid too. Sports betting generated 3.72 billion dollars in state taxes in 2025, led by New York at 1.32 billion dollars under its effective 51.8 percent rate, with Illinois at 557 million dollars. Declining handle squeezes that line item slowly, because tax rates apply to revenue, and revenue is holding up through hold expansion.

The structural worry for states is the exchange channel itself. Contracts traded on prediction markets sit outside state licensing and state taxes entirely, and under current federal rules they are open to 18-year-olds in most states, while sportsbooks require 21. A migration that starts with novelty bets can end with tax revenue and consumer protections parked on the wrong side of the line. Readers weighing the two formats can use our guide to prediction markets versus sportsbooks.

The volume ledger on the other side keeps growing, and our earlier data check in our look at exchange taker volume measured the same migration from the exchange side, with growth of 27 percent trailing the books' 43 percent over the window we measured then, before the December break widened the gap.

State revenue reports complete the picture. Pennsylvania's monthly release, covered in our note on Pennsylvania gaming revenue, showed the hold expansion pattern at the state level months before the national handle curve turned, which is why the two data sets should be read together rather than separately.

Key takeaways

Search results for sports betting handle and prediction markets this week mix monthly revenue reports with exchange-volume commentary, so the trend line gets lost between state releases. The essentials:

  • Handle fell year over year in eight of the last ten months; September was 13.06 billion dollars across 30 jurisdictions, down 0.7 percent.
  • January through August 2026 combined reached 101.7 billion dollars, up 2.5 percent, but down 2.9 percent excluding the World Cup months.
  • The slide began in December 2025, the month Kalshi's sports volume first topped 5 billion dollars, and the correlation between the two series is minus 0.77.
  • Analysts attribute roughly a third of the slowdown to 4 to 5 percent of handle migrating to exchanges, with most exchange volume coming from states without legal online books, led by California and Texas.
  • Revenue still grew where hold expanded, and state taxes reached 3.72 billion dollars in 2025, led by New York's 1.32 billion dollars.

FAQ

Is prediction markets growth really hurting sportsbooks?

Part of the slowdown, not all of it. Analysts estimate 4 to 5 percent of sportsbook handle has moved to prediction markets, explaining about a third of the decline. Saturation in mature states and lighter promotional calendars explain the rest. The negative correlation between Kalshi's volume and book handle makes some real displacement hard to dismiss.

Which states are losing the most betting volume?

Mississippi has the deepest decline at 20.7 percent, followed by Kansas at 11.2 percent, Pennsylvania at 6.3 percent, New Jersey at 4.2 percent and Nevada at 4.1 percent. New Jersey's full-year drop from 12.8 billion to 12.2 billion dollars is the flagship example of a mature market shrinking two years running.

Why are sportsbook revenues rising if handle is falling?

Because hold is expanding. Operators are keeping a larger share of each dollar wagered, through better pricing, parlay mix and fewer promotional giveaways. Pennsylvania turned a 6.3 percent handle decline into 6.5 percent revenue growth by lifting hold from 9.2 to 10.5 percent, and states collect taxes on revenue, so their take has held up too.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Bottom Ad [Post Page]